That split matters because coaching staffs do not distribute reps the same way in each scenario. In a true open battle, first-team snaps rotate. In a transition battle, the veteran usually starts with the edge while the rookie tries to force a timeline change. Source
Cleveland Browns: the messiest room in the league
If you are looking for the purest quarterback competition, start in Cleveland. ESPN’s post-draft reporting pointed to an unresolved picture built around young passers trying to seize control, and the roster-holes analysis specifically described a three-way battle involving Shedeur Sanders, Dillon Gabriel, and Deshaun Watson. That alone makes it the most consequential offseason race in football, because the Browns are not just choosing a starter; they are choosing a direction. Source
The practical question is simple: who gives Cleveland the cleanest offense by August? Sanders offers the biggest spotlight and probably the highest entertainment value. Gabriel may give the staff a steadier operational option. Watson remains the veteran variable, but the tone of the reporting suggests the Browns are still searching for clarity rather than defending a settled hierarchy. If one of the younger quarterbacks strings together efficient OTA and camp reps, this battle could swing fast.
Indianapolis Colts: Daniel Jones is the favorite, but the room is not quiet
This is not a clean 50-50 race, yet it is far from dead. Earlier offseason reporting made it clear the Colts viewed Daniel Jones as their starter when healthy, and the club extended him accordingly. But the latest wrinkle is Anthony Richardson’s return to the building after trade talk and uncertainty about his future. Shane Steichen said Richardson is “back in the fold,” and also made clear he will get reps during the next phase of work. Source
That changes the conversation. Jones still holds the organizational edge, especially because he was extended and remains the stated plan. But Jones is rehabbing, and Richardson is once again getting a chance to show he still belongs in the Colts’ future. Even if this begins as a battle for QB2, it can become larger if Richardson looks healthy, explosive, and more controlled with his decision-making. It is one of the most important situations to watch because the ceiling gap between the two quarterbacks is still large.
Las Vegas Raiders: bridge veteran or accelerated rookie timeline?
The Raiders technically have stability and uncertainty at the same time. ESPN labeled quarterback as the team’s most improved position after the addition of Kirk Cousins, while NFL.com’s coverage of Fernando Mendoza showed exactly why the rookie’s adjustment period matters: he is learning to play under center in a system that asks more of that footwork than his college offense did. Source
That makes this a classic bridge-vs-upside contest. Cousins gives the staff a professional floor. Mendoza gives the franchise its long-term bet. If the rookie picks up Klint Kubiak’s offense quickly and looks comfortable with the under-center mechanics, he can force the issue. If not, Cousins remains the logical Week 1 answer. Either way, this battle matters because the starter will shape the fantasy value of the entire Raiders offense.
Pittsburgh Steelers: a waiting game is still a quarterback story
Pittsburgh’s situation is unusual because the biggest variable is not a camp rep count; it is Aaron Rodgers’ availability and final status. ESPN projected Rodgers as the likely 2026 starter, which tells you how the organization still sees the room. But until that becomes fully settled, Mason Rudolph and Drew Allar remain relevant names in the background. Source
This is why the Steelers belong on the list even if the battle is indirect. Teams script their entire summer differently depending on who they expect behind center. If Rodgers is in, the offense operates on a veteran track. If he is not, Pittsburgh has to decide whether it wants the safer placeholder or the developmental swing. It is less open than Cleveland or Indianapolis, but it still carries major consequences for the AFC picture.
New York Giants: Jaxson Dart still has to close the deal
Among the softer battles, the Giants are the most interesting. ESPN’s projection points to Jaxson Dart as the 2026 starter, and NFL.com already tagged him as a Year 2 breakout candidate. That sounds settled on paper, but young quarterbacks are never truly done proving themselves until camp and preseason confirm command of the offense. Source
That is what makes this room worth tracking. The Giants do not need a dramatic public competition to create pressure. They just need Dart to show he is ready for the full weight of the job. If he does, the Giants move forward. If he does not, every backup rep and every sloppy preseason series becomes part of a larger conversation.
Final takeaway
The Browns have the truest open fight. The Colts have the most complicated one. The Raiders have the most important rookie-vs-veteran transition. The Steelers still live inside uncertainty, and the Giants need confirmation more than competition. That is the quarterback landscape heading toward training camp: not five identical battles, but five very different tests of patience, timing, and organizational conviction.
References and reporting notes
Confirmed 2026 offseason data used here: official offseason calendar, Colts contract and rehab context, Browns roster-battle reporting, Raiders quarterback transition reporting, and ESPN’s leaguewide quarterback projections.
Analytical projections used here: all battle rankings and likely outcomes in this article are projections based on current reporting, not official team declarations.
Sources:
